Published in the Toronto Sun
I was asked to comment by a newspaper reporter yesterday as I left a seminar for my work. I thought “How cool! I could be in an article!”.
So today I looked online to see what became of my few words and his unintelligible scribbles on his notepad.
“Many end up in homeless shelters,” said Crystle Nyman, of Hamilton’s Micah House, which has fewer than a dozen beds while the number of refugees is rising.
So, he spelled my name wrong, but that’s no big deal. But my work comes across pretty negative. My quote is correct, I guess. But I recall talking about how wonderful the day was and how it was great to see groups working together to help those in need.
Unfortunately, when I read the rest of the article, I noticed other things that are incorrect. Which makes me wonder about newspapers and other articles in general. Most of the time, I’m not familiar enough with a topic to spot a small error. And many, many people will read it and also believe that it is factually true, especially when you are ‘quoting’ someone.
For instance, the article mentions:
Casipullai said the refugees are not eligible for social assistance or government jobs and their children have to pay foreign student tuition.
I know that refugees, even refugee claimants, are eligible for social assistance. And only refugee claimants have to pay foreign student tuition–once you are accepted as a refugee you pay domestic rates. So, many will read this and get their facts wrong, but believe it is correct because it was quoted by someone who obviously knows.
So how many other times does this happen? Do you ever notice this, or is this one just an aberration? It is the Toronto Sun…
But, hey you probably want to read the article in all its glory.
Comments(2)
Hey Crystle!
Glad to have been able to browse your blog – noticed the link at the bottom of your email.
My sense certainly is that this issue is not new – of reporters and journalists using quotes and pieces of information in ways that make the story sound the worst, or most dramatic for the purpose of hooking readers in.
Definitely makes you wonder what you are really reading in your local newspaper!
Jen Burgess, First CRC
I noticed this in particular when the Nursing Home I worked at ended up on CTV on the Whistle Blower Report. CTV didn’t do a good job checking their facts and their report was so close to being entirely false.
It turned me off Media so very much. I was so very shocked and disgusted as to how much in error they were. In my opinion if I were the one talking, I would say that I was lying.
So … I’d say I’m with Jen and you both on this subject.